En
← All articles

Three prices to check before calling a Black Friday offer cheap

The displayed discount, the previous low and a rival’s delivered price answer different questions about a Black Friday offer.

ColumnE-commerceAuthorOpen Market NotesTypeArticle
A crossed-out price tag beside a red price-history line.

Amazon’s U.S. Black Friday Week and Cyber Monday promotion runs from November 19 to 30, according to the company’s event announcement. The price a customer sees can be compared with at least three things: the reference price beside it, a price the same offer reached earlier, and the cost of buying it from another retailer today. The comparison chosen can turn the same price into a large percentage discount, a repeat of an earlier offer, or merely a competitive price.

Profitero+’s November 19 study analyzed online prices for more than 18,000 products at 24 leading U.S. retailers. It reported that average price gaps narrowed year over year in categories including beauty, packaged foods and health and personal care. That is evidence about competition across retailers in the products studied. It cannot validate an individual Black Friday badge or establish how often a particular item was cheaper in the preceding month. A broad study may tell a merchant that competitors are close without settling what to do about any one offer. Its 12-week daily average was calculated before the event, from July 6 to September 27, using identical in-stock items and pack sizes matched within 24 hours, not Black Friday prices.

The crossed-out number and the previous low are not interchangeable

In its November 20 update, Amazon said that an offer carrying its deal badge must be at or below its lowest price over the previous 30 days and show savings against a validated reference, such as List Price. Amazon distinguishes a strikethrough alone from a deal badge. The two checks do different work: the 30-day test compares the offer with itself over time; the reference determines the basis of the displayed savings. Matching the earlier low can meet a test framed as “at or below” without setting a new low.

For illustration, consider an item with a displayed $100 reference price, a $70 offer and a previous 30-day low of $70. The reference-based difference is 30%; the new offer is exactly equal to the earlier low. If a rival has the identical item for $67 plus $8 delivery and Amazon’s $70 includes delivery, the rival’s lower sticker price is not the lower delivered cost. A membership fee or a coupon available to only some buyers may change the comparison. These prices are hypothetical, not findings about a current product. The arithmetic makes sense only once the compared offers are comparable.

A dispute over what belongs in the sample

Groundwork Collaborative’s November 16 analysis examined items featured during the 2024 and 2025 holiday promotions, reporting that nearly three in ten in its sample matched or exceeded the recent comparison price. Amazon disputes the methods and says some featured items had no in-store deal badge, some early deals continued into the main event, and some prices in the study did not match its records. The parties are not simply arriving at two percentages for one clearly identical set of offers. Whether exposure in an event roundup or a badge on the offer page defines inclusion, and where the pre-event window ends, can change the answer. Neither result establishes the price performance of the current event.

A usable audit starts with the exact variant, pack size, seller, location, fulfillment and eligibility, then captures the observed price and time, what the reference is labeled, whether there is a badge, and what the buyer would actually pay. For a mixed basket, check the total after delivery and any thresholds rather than extrapolating from one headline discount. Keep past prices and competing current offers as separate columns in the analysis. A priced-to-market offer may be worth buying without being a fresh markdown; that is a clearer claim than treating every crossed-out number as purchase history.

Information only. No investment, legal, tax, or financial advice.